2020
​Best of Craft Beer Awards, Gold Medal, Razzu! Raspberry Wheat - Fruit Wheat Beer 
Best of Craft Beer Awards, Bronze Medal, 5 Phantoms Pumpkin Spice Barleywine - Aged Beer
Best of Craft Beer Awards, Bronze Medal, 5 Phantoms Pumpkin Spice Barleywine - Pumpkin Spice Beer
Great American Beer Festival®, Silver Medal, 5 Phantoms Pumpkin Spice Barleywine - Pumpkin Beer 

---

 2019
​Best of Craft Beer Awards, Bronze Medal, 5 Phantoms Pumpkin Spice Barleywine
​2019 Ecostar Pollution Prevention Awards, Sustainability Efforts at both Breweries

 2018
World Beer CupSM, Gold Medal, 5 Phantoms Pumpkin Spice Barleywine
Great American Beer Festival® , Bronze Medal, 5 Phantoms Pumpkin Spice Barley Wine
Best of Craft Beer Awards, Gold Medal, Haybag Hefeweizen
Best of Craft Beer Awards, Gold Medal, Flint Creek California Common
Best of Craft Beer Awards, Gold Medal, Don't Call Me Honey Specialty Saison
Best of Craft Beer Awards, Silver Medal, Vorfreude Vienna-Style Lager
​

2017
Great American Beer Festival® , Bronze Medal, 5 Phantoms Pumpkin Spice Barley Wine
North American Brewers Association (NABA), Gold Medal, 5 Phantoms Pumpkin Spice Barleywine
NABA, Gold Medal, Ropeswing Saison
NABA, Gold Medal, Otter Water Session Pale Ale
​NABA, Bronze Medal, Haybag American Hefewizen
Best of Craft Beer Awards, Gold Medal, Razzu Raspberry Wheat
Best of Craft Beer Awards, Silver Medal, Haybag American Hefeweizen
Best of Craft Beer Awards, Silver Medal, 5 Phantoms Pumpkin Spice Barleywine

---

2016
World Beer CupSM, Silver Medal, Haybag American Hefeweizen
Great American Beer Festival® , Bronze Medal, 5 Phantoms Pumpkin Spice Barley Wine
North American Brewers Association (NABA), Gold Medal, 5 Phantoms Pumpkin Spice Barley Wine
NABA, Silver Medal, Haybag American Hefewizen
NABA, Silver Medal, Flint Creek California Common
NABA, Bronze Medal, Otter Water Session Pale Ale

---

2015
NABA, Gold Medal, Otter Water Session Pale Ale

---

2014
NABA, Silver Medal, Corners Porter Coffee Porter

---

2013
NABA, Silver Medal, Haybag Hefeweizen
​